Election Day Results

ACROSS SACHEM, NY — Election Day 2019 proved to be a winning day for most of the incumbents running in the local races covering the Sachem area—except for one where a close margin means an incumbent has fallen unless absentee ballots prove otherwise.

Voters cast their ballots in races for the Suffolk County Executive, Suffolk County Legislature, township races for Brookhaven, Islip and Smithtown, and judicial positions.

Among the most-notable results is the race for Suffolk County Legislator in the 8th Legislative District. Incumbent William J. Lindsay III on the Democratic and Working Families tickets was challenged by Anthony A. Piccirillo on the Republican, Conservative, Libertarian and Independence lines.

The results: Lindsay received 8,907 (49.37%) and Piccirillo received 9,130 votes (50.61%). Incumbent Lindsay lost to challenger Piccirillo by 223 votes based on the Election Day vote count. Absentee ballots have not yet been counted.

Here are the full results for races representing the Sachem area.

Results for Election Day Races for Sachem Communities

Sachem is a broad geographic area, covering Farmingville, Holbrook, Holtsville, Lake Ronkonkoma, and portions of Lake Grove. Sachem includes four Suffolk County legislative districts, all of which are up for election. Sachem spans three townships—Brookhaven, Islip and Smithtown—and each has a variety of races.

County Executive – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Steven C Bellone
DemocraticVotes: 144417 / 54.06%
Protect the TaxpayerVotes: 3626 / 1.36%
14804355.42%
John M Kennedy Jr
RepublicanVotes: 94185 / 35.26%
ConservativeVotes: 18909 / 7.08%
IndependenceVotes: 2773 / 1.04%
11586743.38%
Gregory John Fischer
LibertarianVotes: 3147 / 1.18%
31471.18%
Write-in640.02%

County Legislator, 4th Legislative District – Elect 1

Vote For 1Votes%
David T Bligh
DemocraticVotes: 4532 / 36.74%
Working FamiliesVotes: 307 / 2.49%
483939.23%
Thomas Muratore
RepublicanVotes: 6096 / 49.42%
ConservativeVotes: 1006 / 8.15%
IndependenceVotes: 173 / 1.40%
727558.97%
Stephen Ruth
LibertarianVotes: 221 / 1.79%
2211.79%
Write-in10.01%

County Legislator, 8th Legislative District – Elect 1

Vote For 1Votes%
William J Lindsay III
DemocraticVotes: 8295 / 45.98%
Working FamiliesVotes: 612 / 3.39%
890749.37%
Anthony A Piccirillo
RepublicanVotes: 7279 / 40.35%
ConservativeVotes: 1443 / 8.00%
LibertarianVotes: 189 / 1.05%
IndependenceVotes: 219 / 1.21%
913050.61%
Write-in30.02%

County Legislator, 10th Legislative District – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Joseph G Hagelmann
DemocraticVotes: 4104 / 29.40%
IndependenceVotes: 151 / 1.08%
425530.48%
Thomas Cilmi
RepublicanVotes: 7856 / 56.28%
ConservativeVotes: 1640 / 11.75%
LibertarianVotes: 204 / 1.46%
970069.49%
Write-in30.02%

County Legislator, 12th Legislative District – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Margot E Rosenthal
DemocraticVotes: 5231 / 34.80%
523134.80%
Leslie A Kennedy
RepublicanVotes: 8083 / 53.77%
ConservativeVotes: 1394 / 9.27%
LibertarianVotes: 122 / 0.81%
IndependenceVotes: 199 / 1.32%
979865.18%
Write-in30.02%

Supervisor, Town of Brookhaven – Elect 1

Vote For 1Votes%
William B Ferraro III
DemocraticVotes: 29253 / 35.18%
Working FamiliesVotes: 1860 / 2.24%
3111337.42%
Edward P Romaine
RepublicanVotes: 42790 / 51.46%
ConservativeVotes: 6820 / 8.20%
IndependenceVotes: 1545 / 1.86%
5115561.52%
Junie Legister
LibertarianVotes: 865 / 1.04%
8651.04%
Write-in190.02%

Receiver of Taxes, Town of Brookhaven – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Dominador V Pascual III
DemocraticVotes: 30585 / 37.43%
Working FamiliesVotes: 1726 / 2.11%
LibertarianVotes: 708 / 0.87%
3301940.40%
Louis J Marcoccia
RepublicanVotes: 40372 / 49.40%
ConservativeVotes: 6866 / 8.40%
IndependenceVotes: 1447 / 1.77%
4868559.57%
Write-in190.02%

Superintendent of Highways, Town of Brookhaven – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Anthony R Portesy
DemocraticVotes: 31473 / 37.85%
Working FamiliesVotes: 2206 / 2.65%
LibertarianVotes: 835 / 1.00%
3451441.51%
Daniel P Losquadro
RepublicanVotes: 40567 / 48.78%
ConservativeVotes: 6602 / 7.94%
IndependenceVotes: 1455 / 1.75%
4862458.47%
Write-in180.02%

Councilmember, 3rd Town District, Town of Brookhaven – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Talat G Hamdani
DemocraticVotes: 4108 / 32.51%
Working FamiliesVotes: 200 / 1.58%
LibertarianVotes: 96 / 0.76%
440434.85%
Kevin J La Valle
RepublicanVotes: 6857 / 54.27%
ConservativeVotes: 1139 / 9.01%
IndependenceVotes: 232 / 1.84%
822865.12%
Write-in40.03%

Councilmember, 5th Town District, Town of Brookhaven – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Andrea Stolz
DemocraticVotes: 5113 / 36.23%
Working FamiliesVotes: 368 / 2.61%
548138.84%
Neil Foley
RepublicanVotes: 7046 / 49.93%
ConservativeVotes: 1185 / 8.40%
IndependenceVotes: 249 / 1.76%
848060.09%
Pamela E Smith
LibertarianVotes: 151 / 1.07%
1511.07%
Write-in10.01%

Supervisor, Town of Islip – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Thomas E Murray III
DemocraticVotes: 20354 / 39.26%
Working FamiliesVotes: 1497 / 2.89%
LibertarianVotes: 505 / 0.97%
SAMVotes: 45 / 0.09%
2240143.21%
Angie M Carpenter
RepublicanVotes: 24376 / 47.02%
ConservativeVotes: 4197 / 8.10%
IndependenceVotes: 853 / 1.65%
2942656.76%
Write-in160.03%

Town Clerk, Town of Islip – Elect 1  

Vote For 1Votes%
Joseph L Fritz
DemocraticVotes: 21315 / 41.98%
LibertarianVotes: 514 / 1.01%
2182942.99%
Olga H Murray
RepublicanVotes: 23684 / 46.64%
ConservativeVotes: 4469 / 8.80%
IndependenceVotes: 787 / 1.55%
2894056.99%
Write-in110.02%

Receiver of Taxes, Town of Islip – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Donovan G Currey
DemocraticVotes: 19492 / 37.88%
LibertarianVotes: 488 / 0.95%
1998038.83%
Alexis Weik
RepublicanVotes: 25882 / 50.30%
ConservativeVotes: 4633 / 9.00%
IndependenceVotes: 948 / 1.84%
3146361.14%
Write-in140.03%

Councilman, Town of Islip – Elect 2 

Vote For 2Votes%
Jorge C Guadron
DemocraticVotes: 20516 / 20.78%
LibertarianVotes: 589 / 0.60%
2110521.37%
John C Cochrane Jr
RepublicanVotes: 23229 / 23.52%
ConservativeVotes: 4369 / 4.42%
IndependenceVotes: 750 / 0.76%
2834828.71%
Leigh-Ann M Barde
DemocraticVotes: 20474 / 20.73%
LibertarianVotes: 594 / 0.60%
2106821.34%
Mary Kate Mullen
RepublicanVotes: 22873 / 23.16%
ConservativeVotes: 4543 / 4.60%
IndependenceVotes: 787 / 0.80%
2820328.56%
Write-in230.02%

Receiver of Taxes, Town of Smithtown – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Justin W Smiloff
DemocraticVotes: 6740 / 30.20%
674030.20%
Deanna Varricchio
RepublicanVotes: 12941 / 57.98%
ConservativeVotes: 2210 / 9.90%
IndependenceVotes: 423 / 1.90%
1557469.78%
Write-in50.02%

Councilman, Town of Smithtown – Elect 2 

Vote For 2Votes%
Richard Guttman
DemocraticVotes: 7535 / 17.32%
753517.32%
Thomas Lohmann
RepublicanVotes: 11666 / 26.81%
ConservativeVotes: 2117 / 4.86%
IndependenceVotes: 293 / 0.67%
1407632.35%
Patrica A Shirley
LibertarianVotes: 414 / 0.95%
4140.95%
Richard S Macellaro
DemocraticVotes: 7556 / 17.36%
755617.36%
Lisa M Inzerillo
RepublicanVotes: 11408 / 26.22%
ConservativeVotes: 2151 / 4.94%
IndependenceVotes: 366 / 0.84%
1392532.00%
Write-in110.03%

Justice of the Supreme Court, 10th Judicial District – Elect 6 

Vote For 6Votes%
Stephen J Lynch
DemocraticVotes: 108358 / 7.75%
RepublicanVotes: 101980 / 7.29%
ConservativeVotes: 21788 / 1.56%
23212616.60%
Christopher B Garvey
LibertarianVotes: 9388 / 0.67%
93880.67%
Angela G Iannacci
DemocraticVotes: 109759 / 7.85%
RepublicanVotes: 99732 / 7.13%
ConservativeVotes: 21819 / 1.56%
23131016.54%
Annette Totten
LibertarianVotes: 10954 / 0.78%
109540.78%
David J Gugerty
DemocraticVotes: 106191 / 7.59%
RepublicanVotes: 98091 / 7.02%
ConservativeVotes: 22799 / 1.63%
22708116.24%
Christopher G Quinn
DemocraticVotes: 106014 / 7.58%
RepublicanVotes: 100836 / 7.21%
ConservativeVotes: 23014 / 1.65%
22986416.44%
David P Sullivan
DemocraticVotes: 106514 / 7.62%
RepublicanVotes: 101046 / 7.23%
ConservativeVotes: 22922 / 1.64%
23048216.48%
Thomas Rademaker
DemocraticVotes: 104237 / 7.46%
RepublicanVotes: 97605 / 6.98%
ConservativeVotes: 24090 / 1.72%
22593216.16%
Write-in10490.08%

Family Court Judge – Elect 2 

Vote For 2Votes%
Andrea H Schiavoni
DemocraticVotes: 108988 / 22.16%
ConservativeVotes: 20316 / 4.13%
Working FamiliesVotes: 5097 / 1.04%
IndependenceVotes: 4059 / 0.83%
13846028.16%
Richard Hoffmann
RepublicanVotes: 106010 / 21.56%
LibertarianVotes: 3396 / 0.69%
10940622.25%
Victoria Gumbs Moore
DemocraticVotes: 109717 / 22.31%
ConservativeVotes: 17964 / 3.65%
Working FamiliesVotes: 5155 / 1.05%
IndependenceVotes: 3973 / 0.81%
13680927.82%
Michael P Sendlenski
RepublicanVotes: 103715 / 21.09%
LibertarianVotes: 3238 / 0.66%
10695321.75%
Write-in1110.02%

District Court Judge, 1st District – Elect 1 

Vote For 1Votes%
Edward J Hennessey
DemocraticVotes: 96815 / 44.05%
ConservativeVotes: 16478 / 7.50%
Working FamiliesVotes: 4172 / 1.90%
IndependenceVotes: 3160 / 1.44%
12062554.88%
Karen M Wilutis
RepublicanVotes: 95807 / 43.59%
LibertarianVotes: 3290 / 1.50%
9909745.09%
Write-in560.03%
Load comments